URGENT STATEMENT: Malaysia Must Pursue Alternatives to Immigration Detention for Children Immediately
8 December 2020
8 December 2020
The Asia Pacific Refugee Rights Network (APRRN) calls on the Malaysian government to stop the detention of children, regardless of their status or documentation, and to instead pursue alternative community placements and grant UNHCR timely access to detention facilities.
Children should first and foremost be seen as children, beyond their nationality or status. As caring people, we ought to treat children the way we would want our children to be treated if they were one day faced with a similar situation. Under no circumstances should authorities consciously expose children to harm. APRRN urges Malaysia to follow examples of its neighbours, Thailand and Indonesia, in halting the detention of children on immigration offenses and providing an appropriate alternative placement of children through community-based care.
Through Malaysia’s parliamentary sitting in November, it was revealed that, as of 26 October 2020, 756 children were being held in immigration detention centres nationwide. Out of the 756 children detained, 405 of them were being held without their parents or guardians.
Further, since August 2019, UNHCR has been denied access to the detainees in immigration detention centres. By denying UNHCR access to the detention centres, Malaysia risks engaging in refoulement, sending people owed international protection back to persecution or increasing overcrowding in detention centres and detaining people for years. The denial of UNHCR’s access to detention centres began seven months before the Movement Control Order (MCO) took effect and can therefore not be explained by public health concerns.
Malaysia, although not a party to the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, is a party to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and thus is obligated to protect the rights of all children, including refugee children and asylum-seeking children. The detention of children on immigration grounds, often in “overcrowded cells and inhumane conditions”, as reported by Malaysia’s National Human Rights Commission (SUHAKAM), is shocking and a clear violation of the CRC, as well as Malaysia’s own Child Act of 2001. Furthermore, SUHAKAM has observed throughout detention visits that many unaccompanied children are detained with adults, a practice that increases the risk of abuse and illtreatment of children. The Child Act provides that protection of the state should be afforded to all children regardless of their status, which includes placement and care in a safe community-based setting.
To date, Malaysia’s Ministry of Health reported at least a cumulative of 735 positive cases of COVID-19 throughout immigration detention centres nationwide. In a press briefing on 26 May, the Director General of Health acknowledged that the immigration detention centres are “high-risk areas” for the spread of COVID-19.
APRRN reminds the responsible authorities that international legal provisions are clear that detention of persons can only be applied if necessary and proportionate and as a last resort. Migration-related detention of children cannot be considered a measure of last resort and is never in the best interests of the child and, therefore, should always be prohibited.
We urge the responsible authorities to act in the best interest of the detained children by:
-END-
The Asia Pacific Refugee Rights Network (APRRN) is a network of 430+ civil society organisations and individuals from 29 countries committed to advancing the rights of refugees in the Asia Pacific region. APRRN aims to advance the rights of refugees and other people in need of protection through joint advocacy, capacity strengthening, resource sharing and outreach.
Media Contact
Janeen Sawatzky, Programme Coordinator, APRRN
Tel: +66 (0) 98 252 5102 Email: janeen@aprrn.info Fax: +66 2 234 2679
Themba Lewis, Secretary General, APRRN
Tel: +66 (0) 99 481 1595 Email: themba@aprrn.info Fax: +66 2 234 2679
We strongly believe that the shortage of funding for the Rohingya response is a failure of the United Nations. We are already a significant burden for Bangladesh. This announcement of cutting food rations will create a devastating situation for the Rohingya and will have severe implications, including child labour, human trafficking, child marriage, illegal activities, prostitution, and a hostile environment.
The Royal Thai Government must investigate the death of Aziz Abdullah, 49, a farmer of Uyghur ethnicity, who died on Saturday 11 February in the Suan Phlu Immigration Detention Center (IDC) having spent almost nine years in immigration detention. Aziz Abdullah reportedly died of pneumonia.
APRRN urgently calls on the Bali Process Co-Chairs - Indonesia and Australia - to strengthen regional mechanisms, including activating the Bali Process Consultation Mechanism when boats are in distress at sea. There is an urgent need to address the increasing loss of life at sea, and ensure that failures to conduct rescue at sea within Search and Rescue Zones are not repeated in the Andaman Sea and Bay of Bengal